Follow Dubious Orders or Speak Up

There’s a particular kind of fear that comes with being at the very bottom of the ladder. You’re 23, barely making rent, and suddenly your manager asks you to do something that makes your whole body tense. And the terrible part is that you know the power imbalance is real. One wrong move, and the full-time offer disappears. The nice feedback on your performance review evaporates. You become the intern who was “hard to work with.”

But staying silent has its own cost. You chip away at your sense of judgment, your instinct for what feels right, the future version of yourself you’re trying to build. Once you cross that line the first time, the next time is easier. That slope gets slippery fast.

The HBR framework helped me understand that speaking up is a skill.

Step 1: Admit it’s hard.

Talking to someone like Mr. Moon isn’t just awkward; it feels dangerous. Naming that fear actually makes it more manageable. It reminds me that discomfort doesn’t mean I’m wrong. Rather, it means the stakes are real.

Step 2: Lessen the threat.

Instead of declaring something unethical, I’d anchor the concern in the company’s interest:

“I’m worried that if these firms realize I’m affiliated with Zantech, it could put our relationships at risk.”

It shifts the frame from accusation to stewardship. It signals alignment, not rebellion.

Step 3: Offer a path forward.

Rather than refusing outright, I’d bring alternatives: interviews with our customers, analyst reports, insights from former competitor employees. I’m still doing the work — just not in a way that compromises anyone.

Any place worth working will value that.

Avatar

About the author