Week 5 PSP: Three North Star Metrics
I think what makes these three metrics interesting is that they all try to measure whether users are actually getting value from the product, rather than just counting how many people sign up. However, they also show how focusing too much on one number can create problems.
Airbnb: Nights Booked
Airbnb chose nights booked because it represents successful transactions between hosts and guests. More nights booked generally means more people are using the platform and finding value in it. However, the team could game this metric by encouraging longer stays through aggressive discounts or making cancellations harder. This might increase bookings without necessarily improving the experience or profitability.
Facebook: 7 Friends in 10 Days
Facebook realized that users who connected with at least seven friends within their first ten days were more likely to stay active. This made sense because Facebook becomes more valuable when your friends are on it. However, pushing users to add more friends could encourage meaningless connections or aggressive friend suggestions. Users might reach seven friends without actually building a meaningful social network.
Slack: 2,000 Messages
Slack used 2,000 messages as an indicator that a team had started integrating the platform into its daily work. The idea was that teams communicating regularly were more likely to continue using it. However, focusing too much on message volume could encourage unnecessary conversations, spam, and constant notifications. More messages don’t necessarily mean better communication or productivity.
My Takeaway
Goodhart’s Law argues that when a measure becomes a target, it stops being a good measure. I think all three examples demonstrate this risk. Metrics are useful for understanding behavior, but they shouldn’t become the goal themselves. As a PM, I would want to balance these numbers with retention, user satisfaction, and actual value delivered, rather than assuming that increasing one metric automatically means improving the product.
