Product Sense Pushup 6: Test Cards for Products That Flopped

What gets me about these products is that none of the ideas was completely stupid. Short TV episodes, hands-free AI, fresh juice without the cleanup. I can see why people got excited. But I think the teams got attached to building the solution before checking whether people actually needed it.

1. Quibi

Quibi, a fast fashion do conteúdo chega ao mercado - UOL TILT

We believe: People will pay $5/month for short, professionally produced shows when YouTube is free.

To verify, we will: Show 1,000 people a few licensed short episodes, then offer a refundable $5 preorder for a subscription.

And measure: Actual preorders, not email signups.

We are right if: At least 50 preorder.

I like the short-episode idea. I just wouldn’t spend millions filming shows before testing whether people would pay.

2. Humane AI Pin

Humane Ai Pin Hands-On: The Smartphone Replacement We've Been Waiting For?

We believe: People would rather use a wearable AI assistant than their phones, even at $699 plus $24/month.

To verify, we will: Give 20 people a cheap clip-on microphone connected to a phone-based AI assistant for three days, then offer refundable preorders.

And measure: How many preorder at the real price.

We are right if: At least 5 preorder.

The screenless idea is genuinely interesting. But I’d want to know whether the novelty survived everyday use.

3. Juicero

Juicero packs can be squeezed by hand, so the CEO offers 30-day window for refunds - Neowin

We believe: A $400 press makes prepared juice packs worth more than squeezing them by hand.

To verify, we will: Let 20 people try both methods and offer refundable preorders.

And measure: How many preorder the press.

We are right if: At least 5 preorder.

This one’s almost embarrassing because the cheapest test was literally squeezing the bag.

I think Goodhart’s Law applies here too. Signups and excitement can look like demand, and I know I’d be tempted to count them as validation if I loved the idea.

Avatar

About the author

Leave a Reply