I think all three products made a similar mistake of heavily in building something before proving that customers actually needed it. Here’s how I would have tested their biggest assumptions.
For Quibi:
We believe: Consumers are willing to pay $5/month for professionally produced video content regardless of the existence of platforms offering free access such as YouTube and Tiktok.
To verify, we will: Produce two short episodes of low-cost and launching the same via a landing page where potential subscribers could make pre-orders at the price point of $5/month, with a full refund policy should they not like what they saw.
And measure: The percentage of 1,000 visitors who actually preorder.
We are right if: At least 5% preorder.
For Humane AI Pin:
We believe: Consumers will value the screen-less voice interface to a point where paying $699 + regular subscription fee would be justified over using current phone solutions.
To verify, we will: Provide potential buyers a prototype version for seven days, allowing the user to enjoy its benefits during the testing period, after which he/she will receive a partial rebate amounting to $50 off purchase price of $699.
And measure: How many participants place a deposit.
We are right if: At least 6 of 20 participants commit.
For Juicero:
We believe: Customers value the ease-of-convenience offered by juice machine compared to manually squeezing packets, thus willing to spend $400.
To verify, we will: Provide thirty individuals with demonstrations of both options and requesting them to place pre-orders worth $25 in return for machine.
And measure: How many customers actually preorder.
We are right if: At least 6 of 30 preorder.
Overall Takeaway: The best possible way to confirm customer demand is by charging and seeing if they will actually pay for it rather than polling opinions on concept ideas.
