Case Study Can One Business Unit Have Two Revenue Models?

Isolde’s Market

In Isolde’s market, the company Siiquent targets hospitals and large laboratories that require gene-based diagnostic tools and services. Siiquent operates on a “razor-blade” model, selling diagnostic machines at cost and profiting from the consumable supplies needed for those machines.

Emanuel’s Market

Emanuel’s market focuses on research labs and universities through the company Teomik. Their revenue comes from the sale of sophisticated research instruments, with pricing strategies adapted to customer demands and competitive threats.

Pros and Perils of Revenue Models

Pros of a Single Revenue Model:

  • Simplicity: Streamlines internal processes, training, resource allocation, and performance measurement.
  • Consistency and Focus: Allows the company to develop and scale one model effectively.

Perils of a Single Revenue Model:

  • Inflexibility: May not adapt quickly to dynamic markets and competitive pressures.
  • Customer Dissatisfaction: Risk of losing customers who dislike changes, potentially prompting them to switch to competitors.

Mediating the Merger

To mediate the merger of divisions, it’s crucial to avoid a debate-style confrontation, which often favors the more persuasive speaker. Instead, facilitate a structured meeting where each department head presents their case. After both presentations, conduct a democratic vote to determine the best path forward, ensuring a fair and balanced decision-making process.

Avatar

About the author