Product Sense Pushup 6: Test Cards for Products That Flopped

Week 6 PSP: Test Cards for Products That Flopped

1. Quibi

  • We believe: People are willing to pay for short-form entertainment instead of using free alternatives like YouTube.
  • To verify, we will: Create a landing page advertising Quibi’s shows with a paid subscription option.
  • And measure: The percentage of visitors who complete a paid preorder.
  • We are right if: At least 5% of 1,000 visitors pay for a subscription.

2. Humane AI Pin

  • We believe: People are willing to pay $699 for a wearable AI assistant that replaces some smartphone functions.
  • To verify, we will: Let 30 participants use a basic prototype for a week, then offer them a preorder.
  • And measure: How many participants are willing to pay a deposit after using it.
  • We are right if: At least 10 of the 30 participants place a deposit.

3. Juicero

  • We believe: Customers are willing to pay $400 for a machine that squeezes prepackaged juice instead of using cheaper alternatives.
  • To verify, we will: Show 50 potential customers a demonstration comparing Juicero with manually squeezing the same juice packs, then offer a preorder.
  • And measure: How many customers are willing to purchase the machine after seeing both methods.
  • We are right if: At least 10 of the 50 customers place a deposit.

Reflection

What I found interesting about these products is that they all introduced something innovative, but didn’t sufficiently establish whether customers actually needed it. I think Juicero is the best example because a simple comparison with manually squeezing the packs could have challenged the entire value proposition. These cases show why it’s important to test the riskiest assumption before investing heavily in development, rather than assuming that an interesting product will automatically attract customers.

Avatar

About the author

Leave a Reply